Horizontal Urban Expansion: From Imagination to Reality

24 10 2023 08:22

کد خبر : 9435790

تعداد بازدید : 627

A specialized meeting at the School of Urban Planning, University of Tehran, examined the economic, social, environmental, and spatial implications of horizontal urban expansion and villa-style housing as a proposed solution to Iran’s housing crisis.

A specialized meeting titled “Horizontal Urban Expansion: From Imagination to Reality” was held on Monday, October 9, at the Faculty of Urban Planning, University of Tehran. The meeting aimed to examine the important issue of horizontal urban expansion and villa-style housing, along with the challenges and crises associated with this approach.

The meeting featured presentations by Mortaza Hadi Jaberi Moghadam, faculty member at the University of Tehran; Mahmoud Olad, economics researcher and university lecturer; Gholamreza Kazemian, faculty member at Allameh Tabataba'i University; Kaveh Asadpour, urban researcher and university lecturer; Ali Farnam, expert at the Research Center of the Iranian Parliament; and Mohammadreza Zohraei, urban researcher and sociologist.

Rethinking the Arguments for Horizontal Urban Expansion

At the beginning of the meeting, as an introduction to the discussion, Jaberi Moghadam, a faculty member at the University of Tehran, outlined the arguments put forward by proponents of horizontal urban expansion.

Referring to housing concerns in Iran, he stated that, according to policymakers and relevant officials, the housing crisis is primarily attributed to an insufficient supply of land. They argue that government agencies have exacerbated the problem by withholding and hoarding land. Consequently, they propose villa-style housing, horizontal urban expansion, and the removal of urban growth boundaries as solutions to the shortage of land. However, the question remains: Is this argument justified?

Elaborating on the rationale behind these proposals, he explained that, according to housing and urban planning policymakers, Iran has sufficient land resources, and allocating just 0.5 to 1 percent of the country's total land area to urban development plans would be enough to resolve the housing crisis. Proponents of horizontal expansion also argue that urban densities in Iran are too high and that housing construction should therefore shift toward villa-style development.

Jaberi Moghadam challenged these arguments with clear evidence. According to satellite imagery, the total area occupied by cities and settlements in Iran was approximately 841,000 hectares in 2005. By 2021, this figure had increased to 1.5 million hectares, representing an expansion of approximately 80 percent. Much of this additional urban land was developed on agricultural and orchard lands or within areas previously designated as natural resources.

He further noted that the expansion of urban land areas had generally occurred under pressure from influential individuals and interest groups. Therefore, land hoarding cannot be considered the primary explanation for rising housing prices.

The Economic Implications of Horizontal Expansion

Mahmoud Olad, an economics researcher with experience in studying national development plans at different spatial scales and a university lecturer, then examined housing development policies from an economic perspective.

Referring to the different perspectives on horizontal and vertical urban development, he argued that the choice between these two approaches should ultimately depend on their respective costs. In his words, the key question is what we gain and what we lose through each approach.

Addressing the development of extensive villa-style residential areas, Olad emphasized the importance of transportation. Horizontal urban expansion would increase travel distances to different parts of the city, particularly to economic centers. Moreover, the maintenance costs of detached houses are high and tend to increase over time.

According to the definition adopted by UN-Habitat, a housing unit is more than just four walls; it must also provide security, safety, comfort, and access to services, infrastructure, workplaces, and other activities. Residents are generally interested in living closer to central urban areas in order to reduce transportation costs.

Using Tehran as an example, Olad noted that wealth and political power have been concentrated in the city over the past century. He questioned whether demand for central Tehran would disappear if the city's boundaries were expanded tenfold to accommodate villa-style housing. He pointed to cities such as Parand, Pardis, and Hashtgerd, where the underlying demand for access to Tehran has remained strong despite the development of these new urban areas.

He added that, within Iran's contemporary social structure, proximity to centers of power remains a decisive factor. Tehran continues to have the highest concentration of population and economic activity, as well as strong housing demand. As land values increase in these centers of power, greater productivity and more intensive land use become necessary, consequently encouraging vertical development.

Olad also referred to the high population growth rate during the 1980s. He explained that comprehensive urban plans prepared during that decade generally allocated extensive areas for future urban expansion based on the demographic projections of that period.

For example, the projected population of Maragheh for 2001 was approximately 250,000, whereas the 2006 census recorded a population of only 120,000. The Mehr Housing Project in Maragheh also added 80 hectares to the city's urban boundaries. Nevertheless, years later, housing prices in the city center remained several times higher than those in peripheral areas and newly developed neighborhoods.

Three Levels of Analysis for Horizontal Urban Expansion

Gholamreza Kazemian, a faculty member at Allameh Tabataba'i University, emphasized that horizontal urban expansion cannot be categorically classified as either good or bad in the abstract. Rather, it must be examined within its broader socioeconomic context.

He argued that claims about the lower costs of horizontal development require a closer examination of the types and amounts of costs involved, as well as the sources of financing. He proposed examining horizontal urban expansion at three different levels:

1. As a Construction Project

At this level, civil engineers and architects estimate construction costs, which can be divided into three main categories: land; construction materials and equipment; and legal, administrative, and regulatory expenses.

2. As an Urban Planning and Development Issue

At the urban planning level, approximately 60 percent of urban land is allocated to spaces with different types of uses, including both revenue-generating and non-revenue-generating functions. In fact, around 50 percent of these spaces are non-revenue-generating.

Consequently, every square meter of residential space should be accompanied by approximately one square meter of land allocated to public services. A sprawling city also entails higher maintenance costs. At densities of up to 100 people per hectare, the per capita cost of urban maintenance decreases by approximately 90 percent as density increases. Beyond this point, the per capita cost of managing the city declines significantly with increasing density before eventually stabilizing.

3. As an Urban Policy and Governance Issue

At the level of urban policy, horizontal expansion must also be evaluated in relation to broader development objectives. For example, is food security considered a national development priority?

This question becomes particularly important given the possibility of future food supply crises in Iran. Through horizontal expansion, productive agricultural land is transformed into urban land, turning productive territories into spaces primarily characterized by consumption.

Furthermore, horizontal urban expansion can intensify rent-seeking opportunities and conflicts of interest in areas such as the urban environment, security, and safety. These developments may ultimately serve the interests of powerful landowners and influential groups rather than the broader public interest.

Conclusion

The meeting examined the challenges and implications of horizontal urban expansion, particularly in cities such as Tehran. The experts emphasized that within academic discussions, there is no universally accepted prescription that can be presented as the single best solution to urban problems. Such proposals must instead be critically examined in their specific economic, social, environmental, and spatial contexts.

The full video recording of the meeting is available through this link.

Related Pages

Morteza Hadi Jaberi Moghadam

2026 04 Nov